— we were coming
Putting Names To Faces Is The Easy PartIt’s Remembering What To Forget That’s Tricky
Hats off to Gary Porto for naming names. Thirty out of 36 from Mrs. Kaaber’s 5th grade class picture, to be precise. Read his comment to get them all, but first let me tackle his misses.
On the floor, fourth from the left, no, I have no idea who that guy was either. But I hope he’s still enjoying a nice life.
Second row, seated, all girls. (Did anybody notice that the class evenly divided by...gender?) That’s Valerie Salvani, second from the left, between Geraldine Santoro and the lovely Florence Cancro (the only white child from our class who lived in my neighborhood). I gotta dispute the sixth from the left (one of only two girls not wearing the white blouse as ordered). You named her Debra Brown, but my old brain flashed Miriam Williamson as soon as I saw her (again.) Until one or the other of them pipes up, only the Internet will know for sure. I also believe that’s Randy something (Feit?) next to Laurel Waldman.
Third row, standing, and I must challenge again. I’m pretty sure the first from the left was named Jerome. He was one of very few black kids in the class (like the one I swear is Miriam) who didn’t live in my neighborhood. It put a distance between him and me that was not much different than the one between me and everyone else I never saw after school. But I know his name was Jerome.
Yes, I thought that was Peter Bonanno next to Jerome. If anyone asks (hint) I’d love to tell you the story of our competition in the Fifth Grade Science Fair, or rather un-fair as I saw it. Poor Joann Petrozola. Through no fault of her own, as far as I can remember, she was one of those kids treated like she had cooties or something. Something about her name, like “petrified” I think. No book of petty grade school cruelties could ever be definitive or even complete. I’d say my crush on Mary Maestri was terrible and hopeless, but weren’t they all? You forgot to name Isabel Gonzales (8th from left). She was another of the very few non-blacks (what we now call Hispanics) that lived in my neighborhood, though she didn’t really socialize with us and moved away sometime in Junior High School.
I’m sure your failure to name Elissa Conte next to Isabel was an oversight :)
Sorry to hear we lost Barbara Needleman young, to cancer. Didn’t she also have a cousin with the same last name in at least one of our classes?
As Tommy Skeeter reminded you on Facebook, that was Preston Jones standing between Hannah Kleiger and Ed Harper at the end of the row. To say he was my chief tormentor in Junior High, and died a drug-related death sometime while I was in college does not begin to explain the effect he had on the passionate defense of my individuality I developed in high school.
Ed Harper and I started in the sandbox next to his house, less than around the corner from mine, and over 50 years later we remain best friends in the oldest sense of the phrase. And yes, his eyes are still hazel-electric.
Top Row: Kenny Balban was kind enough to drop this comment on our challenge. That’s Eddie White fourth from left and maybe Eddie Began next to him. I can’t place his face, but his size reminds me of a wanna-be bully in the class, and we’ve named all the other “big” guys. That’s me next to Joe Mangione, who I remember as a gentle giant, and Israel Milstein, perhaps my chief academic competitor besides Hanna. I grew to be 6’7” by the time I graduated college; it’s humbling to see that in fifth grade I was no taller than Izzy Milstein.
There will be more to this challenge: do all stay tuned and feel free to comment.
Recent Comments